German Appeals Court Confirms Ban and Damages Against YouTube-DL Host in Stream-Ripper Battle
The Hamburg Appeal Court has upheld a ruling against YouTube-DL's web hosting provider, reinforcing the music industry's ongoing efforts to combat stream-ripping services.
The court dismissed the defendant's appeal entirely, maintaining both the injunction to stop hosting YouTube-DL and the original damages order. This decision, which cannot be further appealed, marks a significant victory for the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry (IFPI) and Germany's Bundesverband Musikindustrie (BVMI).
Hamburg canal illuminated at night
YouTube-DL, a software tool that enables users to download audio from YouTube videos, has been a target of industry legal action for years. The IFPI emphasized that this software has enabled numerous stream-ripping services to illegally obtain music from licensed platforms, depriving artists and rightsholders of revenue.
This ruling sends a clear message to both ripping service operators and online intermediaries that facilitating illegal content downloading will have consequences. The decision reflects a broader global crackdown on stream-ripping services, with similar legal actions occurring in India, the UK, and other nations.
Recent industry efforts have also expanded to combat fake streaming services. Notable actions include:
- Takedowns of fake stream providers in Canada (March 2024)
- Court-ordered shutdown of Germany's PimpYourFollower.de (August 2024)
- Ongoing challenges with replica sites, such as RatingHero24.de emerging to replace banned services
The music industry continues to face challenges in combating both stream-ripping and artificial stream manipulation, particularly as streaming revenue growth slows and concerns about streaming fraud schemes increase.